Grade D Air Quality Cities
43 cities with below average air quality
Grade D means below-average air quality with frequent unhealthy days and concerning trends. These cities are scored using 10 years of EPA Air Quality System data, weighted across 5-year median AQI (40%), trend direction (30%), unhealthy days per year (20%), and worst-pollutant severity (10%).
What "Grade D" Actually Means
A Grade D means a 5-year median AQI elevated above the U.S. average (typically 80-95), often with worsening trends or a high count of unhealthy days. These cities have meaningfully more air pollution than the typical U.S. metro, and the daily picture often swings into the "Unhealthy for Sensitive Groups" or "Unhealthy" range during peak season.
Sensitive groups — children, pregnant women, older adults, people with asthma, COPD, heart disease, diabetes — should treat AQI alerts as essential daily input. Healthy adults will start feeling effects (eye/throat irritation, mild breathing difficulty during exercise) on the worst days and should plan accordingly. Outdoor workers face the highest occupational exposure.
Grade D and Daily Life
On flagged days, sensitive groups should avoid outdoor exertion and keep windows closed. Schools in Grade D areas often run "indoor recess" protocols and cancel outdoor sports practices when AQI exceeds 150. A HEPA air cleaner sized to a bedroom or family room is a worthwhile investment for any household.
Long-Term Health Picture
Long-term residence in Grade D cities is associated with substantially higher asthma incidence, accelerated lung function decline, and elevated cardiovascular mortality. Children growing up in these areas show measurably reduced lung function as adults — an effect that does not fully recover after relocation.
Where Grade D Cities Cluster
Grade D cities typically share one of three patterns: California Central Valley geography (pollution trapped between mountain ranges with limited ventilation), wildfire-smoke exposure in the western states, or concentrated industrial and freight corridors (parts of the Ohio Valley, Houston ship channel, port-adjacent neighborhoods).
Among the 43 Grade D cities tracked here, the largest concentrations are in CA (13), IL (6), CO (4), NM (3), TX (3). The dominant pollutant in these cities is PM2.5 (21 cities), followed by Ozone (21), PM10 (1).
All Grade D Cities
| City | State | 5yr Avg AQI | Trend | Worst Pollutant |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Butler, Ohio | OH | 50 | Worsening | Ozone |
| Codington, South Dakota | SD | 40 | Worsening | PM2.5 |
| Cook, Illinois | IL | 57 | Stable | PM2.5 |
| Dona Ana, New Mexico | NM | 54 | Stable | Ozone |
| Douglas, Colorado | CO | 47 | Worsening | Ozone |
| DuPage, Illinois | IL | 49 | Worsening | PM2.5 |
| Jackson, Mississippi | MS | 46 | Worsening | PM2.5 |
| McLean, Illinois | IL | 48 | Worsening | PM2.5 |
| Siskiyou, California | CA | 41 | Worsening | Ozone |
| Uintah, Utah | UT | 51 | Worsening | Ozone |
| Valley, Idaho | ID | 37 | Worsening | PM2.5 |
| Boulder, Colorado | CO | 50 | Worsening | Ozone |
| Henderson, Kentucky | KY | 53 | Worsening | PM2.5 |
| Neosho, Kansas | KS | 48 | Worsening | Ozone |
| Sanders, Montana | MT | 36 | Worsening | PM2.5 |
| Sangamon, Illinois | IL | 46 | Worsening | PM2.5 |
| Asotin, Washington | WA | 43 | Worsening | PM2.5 |
| Eddy, New Mexico | NM | 47 | Worsening | Ozone |
| SONORA, Country Of Mexico | MX | 44 | Worsening | Ozone |
| Weld, Colorado | CO | 53 | Worsening | Ozone |
| Fresno, California | CA | 68 | Improving | Ozone |
| Jefferson, Colorado | CO | 47 | Stable | Ozone |
| Rock Island, Illinois | IL | 47 | Worsening | PM2.5 |
| Stanislaus, California | CA | 57 | Improving | PM2.5 |
| Winnebago, Illinois | IL | 48 | Worsening | Ozone |
| Imperial, California | CA | 61 | Improving | PM2.5 |
| Kings, California | CA | 64 | Improving | Ozone |
| Placer, California | CA | 54 | Worsening | Ozone |
| Tarrant, Texas | TX | 53 | Worsening | PM2.5 |
| Catano, Puerto Rico | PR | 42 | Worsening | PM2.5 |
| Clark, Nevada | NV | 62 | Stable | Ozone |
| Kern, California | CA | 77 | Improving | Ozone |
| Bernalillo, New Mexico | NM | 59 | Worsening | Ozone |
| El Paso, Texas | TX | 60 | Worsening | PM2.5 |
| Mono, California | CA | 33 | Worsening | PM2.5 |
| Salt Lake, Utah | UT | 57 | Worsening | Ozone |
| Pinal, Arizona | AZ | 66 | Improving | PM10 |
| Harris, Texas | TX | 59 | Worsening | PM2.5 |
| Tulare, California | CA | 75 | Improving | Ozone |
| Plumas, California | CA | 52 | Worsening | PM2.5 |
| Los Angeles, California | CA | 75 | Improving | PM2.5 |
| Riverside, California | CA | 82 | Improving | Ozone |
| San Diego, California | CA | 67 | Stable | PM2.5 |
Frequently Asked Questions
A Grade D means a 5-year median AQI elevated above the U.S. average (typically 80-95), often with worsening trends or a high count of unhealthy days. These cities have meaningfully more air pollution than the typical U.S. metro, and the daily picture often swings into the "Unhealthy for Sensitive Groups" or "Unhealthy" range during peak season.
43 of 1,020 monitored US cities currently have a Grade D Air Quality rating, representing 4.2% of all tracked areas.
Sensitive groups — children, pregnant women, older adults, people with asthma, COPD, heart disease, diabetes — should treat AQI alerts as essential daily input. Healthy adults will start feeling effects (eye/throat irritation, mild breathing difficulty during exercise) on the worst days and should plan accordingly. Outdoor workers face the highest occupational exposure.
On flagged days, sensitive groups should avoid outdoor exertion and keep windows closed. Schools in Grade D areas often run "indoor recess" protocols and cancel outdoor sports practices when AQI exceeds 150. A HEPA air cleaner sized to a bedroom or family room is a worthwhile investment for any household.
Grade D cities typically share one of three patterns: California Central Valley geography (pollution trapped between mountain ranges with limited ventilation), wildfire-smoke exposure in the western states, or concentrated industrial and freight corridors (parts of the Ohio Valley, Houston ship channel, port-adjacent neighborhoods).
/methodology
The this entity category groups every U.S. air quality and pollution monitoring entity sharing this attribute. The list above is the data; the paragraphs below explain what the grouping means against the broader the EPA Air Quality System (AQS) distribution and how to read the relative rankings within the category.
For readers using this category as a starting point, the per-entity detail pages linked from the table above carry the underlying the EPA Air Quality System (AQS) data in full. The category-level view is the filter; the per-entity pages are the actual answer.
Source: EPA Outdoor Air Quality Data, 2026.